fbpx
Connect with us

Social Stories

Lawyers Explain Why No Charges Can Be Made Against Jocelyn Chia, Even If She Comes to M’sia

Published

feat image jocelyn chia action
Source: Twitter & Teras

Follow us on Facebook, Youtube, Twitter, and Instagram for the latest stories and updates daily.

More than 2 weeks after her infamous standup comedy video became viral, Jocelyn Chia and her antics are still hotly being discussed by the Malaysian public.

In fact, the authorities have also issued several statements about taking legal action against Chia for the standup routine. These include the Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM), which sought Interpol’s help to locate and identify the US comedian.

find 5

While a majority of Malaysians were enraged by Chia’s ‘tasteless’ joke, many saw PDRM’s actions as a bit over the top and a waste of time as the resources could be used for other, more pressing matters.

Furthermore, doubts have risen about whether legal action can actually be taken against the comedian, as she’s not even Malaysian or living here.

Screenshot 2023 06 08 103212

So, can Chia actually be charged in our country for the video? To find out, we’ve gotten in touch with a couple of Malaysian lawyers and here’s what they got to say.

PDRM’s investigations against Chia

Speaking to WORLD OF BUZZ, lawyers Luqman bin Mazlan and Mohd Irzan Iswatt, both partners at Kuala Lumpur-based law firm ADIL Legal, asserted that any charges against Chia must be made under provisions with extra-territorial jurisdiction.

This is because the comedian is not a Malaysian citizen or permanent resident. Furthermore, the video of the standup routine was recorded outside of Malaysia, specifically at the Comedy Cellar in New York, United States.

money 2

Luqman said that based on the statement by then Inspector-General of Police (IGP) Datuk Seri Acryl Sani on the matter, PDRM is investigating the comedian under Section 504 and 505(c) of the Penal Code, as well as under Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998.

Section 504 of the Penal Code is for intentional insult with intent to provoke a breach of the peace and Section 505(c) of the Penal Code is for statements conducing to public mischief. Meanwhile, Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 is for improper use of network facilities or network services.

130810506 l

For illustration purposes

Hence, should the authorities want to charge Chia under these provisions, Luqman and Iswatt stressed the provisions themselves must be extra-territorial in nature. Well, spoilers alert, they’re not!

Extension of the Penal Code to extra-territorial offences

Iswatt elaborated that provisions with extra-territorial offences under the Penal Code are prescribed under Section 4 of the Code below:

He further asserted that based on Section 4, only provisions under Chapter VI, VIA and VIB shall be deemed as extra-territorial offences, or in other words, can be applied to non-Malaysian citizens or permanent residents and committed outside of our country.

However, Section 504 and 505(c) of the Penal Code is part of Chapter XXII, hence the provisions don’t have extra-territorial jurisdiction. Applied to Chia’s case, given that she’s not a Malaysian citizen or permanent resident and that the offence was committed outside of the country, no action can be taken against her, even if she sets foot in Malaysia.

Extra-territorial offences under the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998

This is also the case for offences under the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998. Iswatt elaborated that Section 4 of the Act prescribes that any extraterritorial application of the legislation is only applicable to persons outside of Malaysia if:

  • The person is a licensee under the Act
  • Provides relevant facilities or services under the Act

Both definitions are not applicable to the US comedian, hence she may not be charged under the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 too.

Luqman concurred with this and provided the judgement of the case of Amin Rayan v Menteri Dalam Negeri & ORS [2015] 8 CLJ 165 which is relevant to this discussion below:

“our domestic law provides for the operation of our law beyond our territorial limits only to offences under the Official Secrets Act, the Sedition Act, and to offences under Chapters VI, VIA, and VIB of the Penal Code. Our law does not extend to other offences committed beyond our territorial limits, even if it is an offence committed in Malaysia.

“The law of a requesting state may provide for its jurisdiction differently. But in relation to the corresponding offence in Malaysia, we need to look at our law. If there is no corresponding offence in Malaysia, then requisition must be refused, regardless of whether the requesting state has local or extraterritorial jurisdiction.

“Thus, the key to unravel a requisition for the return of a criminal fugitive is the corresponding offence in Malaysia which must have extraterritorial effect.”

Screenshot 2023 06 09 112202

Let’s hope that the explanation by both Malaysian lawyers clears the air regarding the matter. As many commenters online have said before, maybe it’s best to put our resources into more pressing matters.

What do you guys think of the whole Chia situation? Share your thoughts with us in the comments.

 

Also read: M’sian Make Up Artist Hilariously Transforms Himself Into You Know Who!

My Post 1 2023 06 22T144820.697

Source: BERNAMA
Source: 123RF
Source: 123RF

Follow us on Facebook, Youtube, Twitter, and Instagram for the latest stories and updates daily.



Just In

My Post 1 2025 02 17T172100.668 My Post 1 2025 02 17T172100.668
News12 hours ago

Fire at Pattaya Cannabis Cultivation Centre Leaves Residents & Tourists in “High Spirits”

The popular city of Pattaya, Thailand, allegedly heard echoes of laughter on February 13 (Thursday), following a fire at a...

collage 53 1 collage 53 1
News13 hours ago

SJKC Schools in 2 States Have ZERO Chinese Pupils Enrolled in Year 1, Rely on Other Races to Survive

A Chinese primary school in central Johor and Perlis are now relying on students from other ethnic groups for support...

My Post 1 2025 02 17T154547.905 My Post 1 2025 02 17T154547.905
News13 hours ago

PDRM: Court Held British Man’s Passport After RM7 Parking Dispute Until Case Was Classified as DNAA

Last week, it was reported that a British tourist claimed to be stuck in Malaysia following a parking lot dispute...

feat image plknn feat image plknn
News14 hours ago

PLKN 3.0: M’sians Who Fail to Show Up After Being Selected Can Face Up to 6 Months in Jail, RM3,000 Fine or Both

Previously, we shared how the National Service Training Program (PLKN) is now officially back after a 7-month hiatus, with PLKN...

collage 51 1 collage 51 1
News15 hours ago

Pregnant Woman’s Bizarre Craving for a Summons From Police Turns Into Fun Skit as Officers Play Along

During pregnancy, the body sends all kinds of new signals and sensations, and cravings are definitely part of the mix....

feat image n3nen feat image n3nen
News15 hours ago

22yo Woman Drives BMW with “N 3 NEN” Plate Number for Content, Gets Apprehended & Fined by Police

A 22-year-old woman in Malang in East Java, Indonesia, was apprehended by the local police recently for driving a BMW...

My Post 1 2025 02 17T131533.088 1 My Post 1 2025 02 17T131533.088 1
News16 hours ago

Good Samaritan Stops to Help Accident Victims on Karak Highway, Tragically Dies After a Car Crashes Into Him

A good samaritan’s attempt to help accident victims ended in tragedy when he died from being hit by a car...

collage 50 1 collage 50 1
News17 hours ago

“He’s a bad man” – Chinese Boy Calls Police on Own Father, Accuses Him of Stealing His Ang Pow Money 

A young boy bravely called the police himself after he accused his own dad of “stealing” the Ang Pow money...

Announcement

Latest Videos



TRENDING TODAY