Connect with us

News

KL Sinkhole: DBKL Has Immunity from Being Sued by Victim’s Family, Even If It Failed to Ensure Site’s Safety

Published

feat image sue kl sinkhole
Source: The Malaysian Reserve & Sin Chew Daily | Facebook & Noor Fahmey Md Azhar/Astro Awani | X

Follow us on Facebook, Youtube, Twitter, and Instagram for the latest stories and updates daily.

A tragic incident rocked our country recently involving a woman who was buried underground after a sinkhole suddenly appeared in Kuala Lumpur’s Jalan Masjid India.

After 9 days of search and rescue (SAR) operations by the authorities, the victim, 48-year-old Indian national Vijayaletchumi has yet to be found and on Saturday (31 August), the operation has officially been called off.

The distraught family ultimately understands the decision to call off the SAR and on Sunday (1 September), they performed final rites for the victim in a sombre religious ceremony before leaving Malaysia.

While the Government is considering giving compensation to the family for the incident, 1 question many have posed online is whether the victim’s family can take legal action against the Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) for what had happened.

This article seeks to find that answer and accordingly, we’ve gotten in touch with a seasoned legal practitioner and here’s what he has to say.

 

Civil action under the torts of Negligence and Breach of Statutory Duty

Speaking to WORLD OF BUZZ, Malaysian lawyer Mohd Irzan Iswatt, a partner at Kuala Lumpur-based law firm ADIL Legal, asserted that the victim’s family may initiate a civil suit against DBKL.

Given that the city council is a public authority, the civil suit can fall under Breach of Statutory Duty or Negligence.

Image 104
Source: The Sun

For Breach of Statutory Duty, the right to sue originated in the statute and the remedy to claim damages is provided by the common law. Meanwhile, for Negligence, the right to sue doesn’t originate in statute.

The statutes which established DBKL’s statutory duties

As for the Jalan Masjid India sinkhole, Iswatt asserted that the applicable statutes establishing DBKL’s statutory duties are the Street, Drainage and Buildings Act 1974 and the Earthworks (Federal Territory of Kuala Lumpur) By-Laws 1988.

Section 4 of the Street Drainage and Building Act 1974 may apply to the sinkhole incident, as the provision prescribes for local authorities to maintain and repair public streets, which is what the location of the incident was. 

Screenshot 2024 08 30 at 3.53.37 PM

Furthermore, given that the sinkhole could be caused by earthworks done in the area, Section 70A of the Act below may also apply, with more detailed responsibilities further prescribed in the Earthworks (Federal Territory of Kuala Lumpur) By-Laws 1988.

Screenshot 2024 09 02 at 12.12.55 PM

 

DBKL and other local authorities have legal immunity 

For illustration purposes

However, these are all rather academic as in Malaysia, local authorities such as DBKL are immune from any action, claim, liabilities or demand.

Iswatt revealed that this is prescribed under Section 95 of the Street, Drainage and Buildings Act 1974 below:

Screenshot 2024 09 02 at 12.13.29 PM

Essentially, this provision gives legal immunity to local authorities such as DBKL from any civil action, even if they didn’t carry out their duties as prescribed by the Act and its bylaws.

In fact, they’re immune from any legal liability even if they fail to carry out any inspection to ensure the Act or any of its by-laws are complied with!

 

The Federal Court ruling for a civil suit on the Highland Towers tragedy

the infamous highland towers area could be redeveloped very soon world of buzz 4

Source: Fire and Rescue Academy Malaysia | Facebook

Iswatt referenced the case of Majlis Perbandaran Ampang Jaya v Steven Phao Cheng Loon & 81 Others [2006] MLJU 49, in which MPAJ was taken to court as the 4th Defendant in a civil suit for the Highland Towers tragedy which took 48 lives.

When the case reached the Federal Court, it was held that MPAJ as a local authority was immune from liability for the incident.

the infamous highland towers area could be redeveloped very soon world of buzz 5

Source: Novista

In his judgment, Justice Abdul Hamid Mohamad asserted that if local authorities were to be made liable, it would open the floodgates to further claims for economic loss, and this would deplete their financial resources needed for the provision of basic services and infrastructure for the general public.

Abdul Hamid further held that it would be unfair for rate payers’ money to be used to pay out damages for the local authorities’ negligence.

the infamous highland towers area could be redeveloped very soon world of buzz

Source: The Star

The learned judge asserted,

“In my view, the provision of basic necessities for the general public has priority over compensation for pure economic loss of some individuals, who are clearly better off than the majority of the residents in the local council area,”

Hence, the Federal Court has set a binding precedent that local authorities are immune from any liability. Of course, it’s only applicable to any future cases with similar facts and circumstances, otherwise, the ruling is only persuasive.

Hence, it is up to the court to decide whether DBKL is liable for any claim of damages from the victim’s family should the latter decide to initiate a civil suit.

Image 103
Source: Wikipedia

For illustration purposes

However, as we’ve elaborated above, the outlook doesn’t look too positive.

 

Also read: No Need to Declare Jalan Masjid India a Danger Zone Despite Sinkhole Incident, PDRM Says

collage 125

Follow us on Facebook, Youtube, Twitter, and Instagram for the latest stories and updates daily.



Just In

collage 66 collage 66
News17 minutes ago

M’sian Factory Worker Dies After Colliding With PDRM Motorcycle During Police Escort

A man died after the Yamaha 135LC motorcycle he was riding collided with a police escort motorcycle at Kilometer 5.3...

certft certft
News3 hours ago

Forged Birth Certificate Syndicate Busted, Documents Allegedly Sold for Up to RM10,000

A syndicate involved in forging documents for late birth registrations is reportedly charging between RM8,000 and RM10,000 for each processed...

masft masft
News4 hours ago

MAS Flight from Manila Forced to Return After One of Its Engines Catches Fire, No Injuries Reported

A Malaysia Airlines flight from Manila to Kuala Lumpur had to return to Ninoy Aquino International Airport yesterday afternoon (March...

collage 61 collage 61
News23 hours ago

Court Tells Aliff Syukri to Enter Defence Over Obscene Raya Music Video Charges from 3 Years Ago

Malaysian businessman and self-proclaimed number 1 singer, Dato Seri Aliff Syukri, released his latest Raya song, Raya ya ya, last...

collage 59 collage 59
News24 hours ago

14yo School Athlete in Malacca Dies After Collapsing During Recess Time

A secondary school male student in Malacca passed away after collapsing near the field while walking to the canteen yesterday...

collage 57 collage 57
News1 day ago

Kajang Man Punches & Breaks Nose of Unlicensed 17yo Driver After Misunderstanding, Gets Arrested by PDRM

A Malaysian man allegedly punched and broke the nose of a teenage driver in Kajang, causing the latter to bleed....

riotft riotft
News1 day ago

PDRM Arrest 13 Foreign Workers for Attempting to Incite Riot Following Protest in Teluk Intan

The police have arrested 13 foreign factory workers in connection with a riot after a viral clip showed hundreds of...

syedft syedft
News1 day ago

Syed Saddiq & Bella Astillah Team Up to Distribute RM1.36 Million Worth of Aid to Muar Residents

A couple of weeks back, Syed Saddiq revealed that his choice to start his modeling career was to raise funds...

Announcement

Latest Videos



TRENDING TODAY